Ayn Rand and Academic Philosophers

University of Texas philosophy professor Keith Burgess-Jackson, blogging at Anal Philosopher, has posted a considerate and fair-minded response to the question “Why do so many academic philosophers dismiss Ayn Rand?
(As he later clarifies, these comments explore philosophers’ nonrational grounds for dismissing Rand. And a later thread notes our interview with Mimi Reisel Gladstein touching on this same subject.)
One interesting excerpt:

Deep down, philosophers, like other writers, want to be read. Ayn Rand is read. Many more people have read her work than that of John Rawls, W. V. O. Quine, and other darlings of academic philosophy. I?m only speculating, but I think philosophers envy Rand?s literary success. People despise and belittle those they envy. Rand also had (and has) disciples. Many of them. Philosophers, like other scholars, want disciples to carry on their work and to disseminate their views, but most have only a few, if any. No self-respecting philosopher would admit it, but there is a great deal of envy of Rand in the discipline.

See Burgess-Jackson’s full commentary for additional illumination.

2004 Coca-Cola Scholar Nicole Newman

Nicole NewmanSan Diego-area high school graduate Nicole Newman is one of this year’s Coca-Cola Scholars.
And she’s yet another bright, ambitious, talented young person whose favorite novel is The Fountainhead:

Few students pack as much into the day as 18-year-old Nicole Newman.
It begins at 4 a.m. with ice skating practice, followed by Advanced Placement courses at school, varsity track practice and a part-time job at Frog’s gym.
And she does it all while maintaining 4.0 grade-point average, coaching children in Special Olympics and taking a youth leadership role at church.
Nicole, a senior at La Costa Canyon High School here, was selected from 80,000 students nationwide to be a 2004 Coca-Cola Scholar.
The honor comes with a $20,000 college scholarship, which will go toward tuition at Dartmouth College where Nicole might major in bio-engineering. […]
Nicole plays the piano, and her favorite book is Ayn Rand’s “The Fountainhead,” though she devours Harry Potter books.

See her full profile at SignOnSanDiego.com for additional information.

Excellent Interview with T.J. Rodgers

Cypress Semiconductor CEO T.J. RodgersDeclan McCullagh (writing for CNet’s News.com) has published an excellent interview with Cypress Semiconductor CEO T.J. Rodgers.
Some noteworthy excerpts:

Q: John Kerry is denouncing “Benedict Arnold” CEOs who send jobs overseas. Is it moral for American companies to increase their overseas outsourcing?
A: It is immoral for any CEO not to run his company in the best possible financial way for his shareholders. I used to hold Kerry’s naive view of the “all American” company, meaning all jobs in America. That was a foolish mistake on my part, and it cost my shareholders a lot of money, until I moved our entire assembly and test operation and several hundred jobs offshore in 1992. […]
Some AFL-CIO activists are pledging to make the offshoring of technology jobs a campaign issue this fall.
The AFL-CIO has been promoting losing economics causes for years. Other than the government members of the union, the AFL-CIO has lost pretty much all of its membership over the last few decades. The AFL-CIO consistently promotes economic policies that harm its own members. […]
Why not [expand your company in California]?
The wage rate is one problem, but it’s surmountable, because the cost of a wafer is only 15 percent labor. So if I paid a 20 percent premium for labor, the wafer would only cost 3 percent more. The killer factor in California for a manufacturer to create, say, a thousand blue-collar jobs is a hostile government that doesn’t want you there and demonstrates it in thousands of ways, through bureaucrats and regulations.
Ayn Rand said no society can jail an honest man. So if you want to use the power of society on citizens, you have to make normal behavior illegal. The zoning ordinances and environmental ordinances are a classic example. I guarantee you that nobody truly understands them, and no plant can meet all of them simultaneously. So you end up with a dynamic that there are no laws, and there are no rules, and you’re completely at the mercy of the local government, and they don’t want you there. And they tell you that. So you go away. That’s why there’s no silicon left in Silicon Valley.

See the full interview with T.J. Rodgers for more gems of insight and wit from this prominent admirer of Atlas Shrugged.
PS. For some video footage, check out this EE Times interview with T.J. Rodgers.

Chat with Yaron Brook and Onkar Ghate

The Objectivism Online web site has published a transcript of their recent live chat with Dr. Yaron Brook, executive director of the Ayn Rand Institute (ARI), and Dr. Onkar Ghate, a senior fellow at ARI.
The conversation includes interesting information, including an update on the Objectivist Academic Center, their plans for the future, and this information about the popularity of ARI’s essay contests and the current sales of Ayn Rand’s books:

Let’s start with essay contests. This year, for the second time, we will have received 14,000 essays from high school students competing in our essay contests. This probably makes ours the largest essay contest in the country. In addition, this year we shipped over 50,000 copies of The Fountainhead and Anthem to high school teachers committed to teaching these books in their classrooms. Imagine a day when we are shipping 500,000 copies a year to such teachers, thus ensuring that millions of college freshmen are exposed to Ayn Rand’s ideas in high school. That day is coming.
The 50,000 books were sent to over 1,000 teachers. Book sales of Ayn Rand exceded 500,000 copies for the second year in 2003. Five years ago there was no formal program at a university in which Objectivism was taught. Today we have such programs at the University of Texas, University of Pittsburgh, and at Ashland University.
In addition, there are programs in which Ayn Rand is significantly featured and taught by Objectivists at Duke University, and next year, at the University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill. Add to that, starting this fall, the business schools at the Universities of Kentucky and South Carolina will be handing out copies of Atlas Shrugged to all incoming undergraduate and graduate business students.

See the full transcript for additional information from Drs. Brook & Ghate.

Regina Ayn Weiler

Regina Ayn WeilerIn the might-make-you-smile category, this article about a 15-year-old college graduate is inspirational:

Note to the person handing Regina Ayn Weiler a diploma at Brevard Community College this afternoon: The petite 15-year-old offers an alarmingly strong hand shake.
And, adds her mom, “She’ll put you on the floor in a second.”
Weiler, known by friends, family and teachers as “Rocket,” is a second-degree black belt in Taekwondo.
After speaking for a few minutes to BCC’s youngest graduate this year, who will earn an associate’s degree, it no longer seems surprising.
For pleasure last summer, Rocket read dictionaries.
“Webster’s,” she said. “Unabridged.”

And…

When she was 8 or 9, Rocket checked 66 books out of Merritt Island Library in one visit. She said she read them within a week.
Perhaps such precocity was destined for a girl named after philosopher and author Ayn Rand, known for her celebration of individuality.

See the full article.

Oliver Stone and Brad Pitt on Remaking the Fountainhead

The purpose of “Media Citings” and “Culture” categories on this blog is to bring some attention to the ways in which Ayn Rand’s work has become a part of the cultural vernacular. As I point out here, in an Atlasphere article (which I have expanded considerably for publication in a Fall 2004 Centenary Culture Symposium in The Journal of Ayn Rand Studies), Rand’s cultural impact is growing at an almost exponential rate. To merely cite the positive and negative cultural references to Rand, however, does not imply a “sanction” of any of the said references. On this blog, I’m mostly playing the role of “messenger”: My posts are more “reportage,” rather than Op-Ed.
So, for example, my comments on “John Galt,” radio pirate, are not a sanction of his radio piracy or even a championing of his battle against the FCC. It is simply a post that illustrates the possible Randian influence on a small group of people. These people invoke the Robin Hood legend in a way that recalls Rand’s own invocation and inversion of that legend; she notes in her description of Ragnar Danneskjold, in Atlas Shrugged, that he is a pirate “Robin Hood who robs the [parasitic] humanitarians and gives to the [productive] rich.” The radio pirates in Denver claim they are “taking radio back from the rich,” but their struggle is against a system of government licensure that enriches those privileged enough to secure the licenses. My post includes no assessment of the legitimacy of their struggle; such an assessment would be well beyond my scope, in this context.
I provide this long prefatory note because what I’m about to report to my Atlasphere readers is that Brad Pitt, mega-star of the new film, Troy, which opens nationwide today, told interviewer Charlie Rose that Oliver Stone?yes, he, of the left, who admires Fidel Castro?was still interested in directing a new version of The Fountainhead.
As he has done on other occasions, Pitt talked glowingly of the science and aesthetics of architecture. Rose asked him if he knew of any way to combine his passion for architecture with his passion for acting; he wondered if there was any “story of a great architect” that might inspire Pitt. “That would go back to The Fountainhead,” Pitt replied. Rose wondered if Pitt would even consider re-making it. Pitt said that the book is “so dense and complex, it would have to be a six-hour movie … I don’t know how you do it under four, and not lose, really lose, what Ayn Rand was after.” But he affirmed his profound interest to star in a re-make, and cited Oliver Stone’s own interest in directing it as a feature film.
Whether you revel in or revile the possibility of a Stone-Pitt collaboration, the fact is that Rand’s work is still inspiring a generation of admirers?left, right, and center?who have been deeply impressed with her paean to individual integrity and authenticity. And in an age that has seen the devastation of the New York City skyline, a skyline that Rand worshiped as “the will of man made visible,” I can think of few novels more in need of a modern re-telling.
So… let the arguments begin over who should direct and who should star in any big-screen adaptation. I’m just a reporter here.

Barbara Amiel and Ayn Rand

Barbara AmielWriting for the Guardian, Catherine Bennett thoughtfully reviews the public life and writings of Barbara Amiel, who was recently fired by the Telegraph over a financial dispute.
The article begins:

It is not difficult to imagine what the Telegraph columnist Barbara Amiel would write about the suspension of the Telegraph columnist Barbara Amiel. In fact she wrote it two months ago when Martha Stewart, another very rich “tall poppy”, was felled by accusations of financial impropriety. “Corporate scandals have created an atmosphere where all public companies are potential wearers of the scarlet letter. Any hint of wrongdoing gets the elders out, solemn and judgmental.”

Ayn Rand is mentioned in passing, and at times Amiel sounds herself like a character befitting Atlas Shrugged.
See the full article for further reading.

John Galt on the Radio

Readers of Atlas Shrugged remember that John Galt made his climactic speech on the radio. Nowadays, there appears to be a real life John Galt, who has joined with two colleagues in pirating the radio airwaves.
This John Galt is attempting “to launch an unlicensed Denver radio operation,” which is “illegal under regulations administered by the Federal Communications Commission,” a commission for which Ayn Rand herself had no great love.
I’m not quite sure if this new John Galt uses Atlas as inspiration, but it’s clear that he and his colleagues, like Rand, have invoked the Robin Hood legend in trying to take back radio from privileged license holders.
(Thanks to Ari Armstrong for alerting me to this story.)

Scottish Artist Jack Vettriano

Jack Vettriano (self-portrait)Writing for Scotsman.com, Brian Monteith draws a comparison between Scottish artist Jack Vettriano and Howard Roark:

THANK goodness for Scottish artist Jack Vettriano. If he didn?t exist we would have to invent him.
There?s an excellent novel written in the 1940s by Ayn Rand called The Fountainhead, which was later made into a film with Gary Cooper in the lead role as the hero, Howard Roark.
The story is simple enough; Howard Roark is an architect who values his work for its own sake, famously saying: “I don?t build in order to have clients; I have clients in order to build.”
The buildings are his creation; he has designed them, toiled over them and brought them into the world. He cannot be corrupted or seduced by the collectivist establishment, which is made up by politicians and officials of the state and by art critics in the press. Ultimately, he demolishes one of his own buildings rather than let it be corrupted by his critics.
Jack Vettriano is a Howard Roark of our times. He paints because he enjoys it; it brings him clients. He is popular because it just so happens that he is in tune with our contemporary longing for nostalgia. He too has toiled over his work, having been self-taught and living from hand to mouth until he became financially successful. Now he enjoys the sweet taste of success.

See the original article for further information about this artist and the establishment that opposes him. You can also see some larger Vettriano prints at bertc.com.